Who Cares What The Dow Did Last Week?

Posted on March 5, 2010
Filed Under Personal Investing

So I’m driving home this past Sunday afternoon with my radio tuned to a New York City all-news station. The hourly 5-minute business report is on, and it wraps up with the “news” that the Dow Jones Industrial Average closed up 4.23 points on Friday, and the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index gained 1.55.

Who was this “news” aimed at? And what purpose did it serve?

At the time of the radio report, the stock market had been closed for almost two full days. Anyone who cared about whether the Dow gained or lost a few points surely knew it by then.

But more importantly, giving that two day old news could easily intimidate non-investors. They would think that those numbers are terribly significant – after all, they were still being announced days after the fact, and they were given to two decimal places.  

“Why else would that smart ‘business’ reporter say them? I guess I don’t understand finance.”

But the fact is, those numbers are not important. For everyone except professional day-trader type investors, the daily close of the Dow is merely noise, a snapshot of a fleeting moment, not worthy of concern for any rational long-term investor.

Worse, the numbers are given as, well, numbers. What in the world does “up 4.23” points mean to your portfolio?  Did the Dow do better because it was up more “points” than the S&P? The only numbers that should be announced on the news programs are percent changes. Anything else is nonsensical because it is presented without context.

In this case, the Dow gained 0.04% while the S&P gained 0.02%. In both cases, the net result would be that most broadly diversified portfolios barely budged from the previous day.

This has been a pet peeve of mine for years. The fashion of announcing point gains is a remnant from the days before calculators. Today there is no excuse for telling the public raw numbers which have no relationship to their nest egg, instead of the far more useful percentage gain or loss.

COMMENTS

12 Responses to “Who Cares What The Dow Did Last Week?”
  1. Ken Salzman on June 4th, 2010 8:54 pm

    I agree, and would go one step further. Reporting the latest “move” of the statistics again only serves those who have been diligently following the numbers on a daily basis. “The Dow gained 2.3%” is even still not relevant if I don’t know where it has been. The casual listener needs to know the actual Dow number as well, to compare with the last time they noticed the number. If the Dow two weeks ago was 10,870 and today “gained 7.5%”, I know nothing, really. I know more if it says, “…gained 7.5% to a close of 10,212”. NOW I know things have been going not so well in the Dow. Even then, the best interpretations are the long-term ones. The hoorah and cheering over the fabulous wonderful super fantastic gains in the market from 2005-2008 were not all that great given that they were just recovering lost ground from the 2000-2005 losses. All of which begs Ken’s original question: “For whom are these numbers being reported?”

  2. Anie on October 16th, 2015 5:56 am

    I purchased this book bescuae I have recently developed an interest in income producing investments. I found it informative,brief and to the point. It gave me a very good jumping off point to look further into this area of investing, and I recommend it to any beginner interested in dividend paying stocks.

  3. http://www.allweb.space/barbarastikker.com on December 5th, 2015 2:05 pm

    I’m impressed. You’ve really raised the bar with that.

  4. http://www.www2go.site/creativelists.blogspot.com on December 7th, 2015 2:49 pm

    Superb information here, ol’e chap; keep burning the midnight oil.

  5. http://www.blrimages.net/ on April 29th, 2016 12:48 am

    Field, I agree with you on the senseles violence, but let me tell you for every death due to gun violence, you probably have two or three deaths by hamburger. That’s no joke! Black people are killing themselves with poor dietary regimen in epidemic proportions.

  6. http://www.sorethumbsblog.com/ on April 29th, 2016 1:30 am

    63. That is ridiculous reasoning. By your logic and hollinger’s logic, every team that is not the Heat is a loser. Why do we even bother to play the games or deal with the long season. Let’s just give the rings to the ringwraths. Let’s not even bother with the nba for the next, say 5 yrs. Let’s just annoint them champions for 5 yrs and move on.it’s just like everyone annointing James and the Cavs as chip winners the last to seasons to only see them eliminated in the playoffs. Please. That’s not news.

  7. car insurance on May 20th, 2016 2:16 pm

    The tax is paid when withdrawn in the plan holders name. In the case of a spouse, there may be attribution of tax back to the contributor if contributions were made within the last 3 years.I hope that helps!Jim

  8. http://www.houseisinthebag.com/ on June 14th, 2016 3:56 pm

    I do not get the JFK being included here by you in this column as, even if he was a democrat and great orator, he and his excellent team did inspire many with genuine hope and his peace corps did do altruistic work all over the globe. JWC & BHO did and do little else than talk with nothing positive to have been attributed to society in general.

  9. http://www.goupbd.com/ on June 25th, 2016 3:46 pm

    I just found out that my cholesterol is in the highest category, including the LDL cholesterol. I am 25 years old, a normal weight, and I have been a vegetarian (but very close to a vegan) for most of my life. I am very upset and confused. Does anyone know why this might be happening?

  10. http://www.gobet33.biz/ on July 5th, 2016 6:06 pm

    The manzanita cave sounds excellent! I love these stories you tell here — your brother up in the pine, and riding your pony to various tree landmarks! Seriously: you had every kid’s American dream! Doesn’t every kid sigh and say, “I wish I had a pony!”?It’s a dream of mine to see the Redwoods someday. Now I’d like to read The Legacy of Luna. I wonder if it’s still in print. . . .Thank you for a beautifully-written comment — including your well-stated conclusions. Total agreement!

  11. http://www.goldenhandssalon.com/ on July 10th, 2016 4:34 pm

    Those look so great… love the idea of rosemary and pineapple… never would have done it on my own. Tart tatin is a real favorite of mine and I've made it with pears and apples… pineapples??? GREAT idea!

  12. http://www./ on July 10th, 2016 10:57 pm

    Beautiful card, a little bit different that we used to from you!! But also beautiful. Could you tell me which computerprogramm you use to make the sketches?? I wnat to buy one, but have a hard time to decide which one is good…. Thanks already!!

LEAVE A COMMENT